The most common mistakes in influencer marketing
I’ll walk through the most common mistakes the way they actually show up in real campaigns. What the mistake really is, what it causes later (because the consequences usually show up weeks after), and how you fix it without killing the whole channel
Finding influencers without vetting
This one almost always starts with good intentions.
You find a creator who looks right with strong visuals and solid follower count. Maybe competitors have worked with them before. On paper, it feels safe.
But numbers in influencer marketing are often just surface signals. They show activity, not influence. And those two things are very different.
A creator can have reach without trust. An audience can watch without listening. And sometimes, the influencer simply never learned how to move people from liking content to taking action.
On top of that, the engagement can be artificial with purchased bots instead of real followers.
What happens next?
The campaign launches and even some views come in. On the surface, everything seems fine. but conversions don’t follow. Why? Because bots don’t buy, and inactive followers don’t care.
That’s when doubt creeps in. The conclusion becomes: influencer marketing doesn’t work for this product.
In reality, the campaign never had a real audience to begin with. The message was delivered into empty space. The brand loses money, but worse than that, it loses confidence in a channel that could have worked perfectly with the right creator.
How you fix it?
Real vetting + analytics dashboards = more confidence.
First, watch how the audience behaves:
-
Are people asking for opinions or just dropping emojis (bots behavior)?
-
Do followers trust recommendations, or ignore them?
-
Has this creator successfully recommended products before?
Next, leverage influencer analytics platforms like IQFluence.
🛑 If more than 15-20% of their audience are suspicious accounts, skip the creators
For example, this is how our clients determine the number of suspicious accounts in IQFluence.
Besides, these are red flags to watch:
-
When an account is following more than 1.5K people, there’s a good chance sponsored posts don’t even reach them. Their feed is simply too crowded, and the algorithm filters aggressively. So, if over 25% follow more than 1,5K people, skip.
-
Another thing that raises questions is inconsistent growth. Sudden spikes in followers followed by flat periods or sharp drops usually signal artificial growth rather than genuine interest building over time.
-
And then there’s story performance. When story views are noticeably low compared to the follower count, it often means the audience isn’t actively engaged or isn’t real in the first place.
-
Next, geography. If someone says they’re in Los Angeles but 60% of their followers are in Brazil or Indonesia, that’s a red flag. For region-specific campaigns, you want at least 70–80% of followers in your target location.
In this type of dashboard, companies analyze the performance of their campaigns in IQFluence.
Green flags to watch:
Stable growth. Healthy accounts tend to grow steadily over time, without sudden jumps or unexplained drops. Why?
Growth looks gradual because real audiences build slowly since people discover the creator, stay, and keep engaging.
Posting rhythm matters too. A consistent cadence, usually two to three times per week, keeps the audience familiar with the creator without overwhelming them. It signals that the account is active, reliable, and still being surfaced by the algorithm.
IQFluence’ audience reachability dashboard. Try it for free for 7-days
And then there’s reachability, which often gets overlooked. When less than 20% of the audience follows more than 1.5K accounts, it’s a strong sign that followers are actually able to see the content in their feeds.
Сommon mistakes influencer marketing hiring
“The biggest influencer marketing controversy I see brands make when hiring influencers is ignoring the brief and the contract or treating them like they’re optional. You think you can just send a vague idea, shake hands, and everything will work itself out. You can’t.
Without a clear brief, the influencer doesn’t really know what you expect. Messaging gets off, deadlines slip, or they post fewer assets than promised. You pay for exposure that doesn’t convert because the rules were never spelled out.
And if you get into tricky territory with rights, usage, or disclosure, you’re exposed legally without even realizing it.
The fix? It is simple, but it takes discipline. The brief and contract are the foundation of the collaboration.
Spell out everything. Deliverables, formats, timelines, messaging guidelines, approvals, usage rights, even what happens if something goes wrong. Make sure the influencer actually understands it. If they can’t repeat it in their own words, it’s not clear enough.”
Skipping it, and even the perfect influencer with the perfect audience can become your most expensive mistake.
Read also: Your guide to influencer marketing contract [+5 free templates]
Failing to monitor campaigns
Failing to monitor campaigns is one of those mistakes that quietly eats your budget and your results without anyone noticing until it’s too late.
You launch a campaign with an influencer, the audience fits, the content is strong, the brief is clear, and you feel confident. You hit go and then walk away, thinking the work is done. The problem?
Social media moves incredibly fast. Engagement can drop, content can go up at the wrong time, or the messaging can drift slightly off-brand. Sometimes posts don’t even go live properly, or the audience reacts in ways you didn’t anticipate. If you aren’t actively monitoring, these issues can snowball before anyone even realizes.
The consequences:
-
Performance suffers because likes, views, clicks, and conversions don’t hit expectations and no one knows why.
-
Money is wasted because campaigns that could have been adjusted mid-flight keep running inefficiently.
-
And perhaps most importantly, brand perception can be damaged.
If an influencer posts something poorly received or slightly misaligned, your brand gets associated with it before anyone has the chance to correct it.
The way to fix it?
-
Start by setting clear goals and KPIs before the campaign launches, whether that’s reach, engagement, clicks, conversions, or story views.
-
Then actively monitor every piece of content, especially in the first day or two after it goes live.
-
Pay attention not just to numbers but to audience sentiment and timing.
-
Communicate constantly with the influencer. If performance is off or content needs adjustment, make the changes immediately.
Monitoring isn’t micromanaging; it’s treating the campaign like a living project that needs guidance, not just a box to check. The moment you stop watching is the moment small problems turn into expensive mistakes.
Using tools like IQFluence to track and optimize campaigns in real time. Why? It pulls everything you need in one clean dashboard, so you don’t need to ask for screenshots.
It tracks CPM, CPV, CPC, CPR, CPA, engagement rate, likes, comments, shares, views. The user doesn’t need to do all the complicated calculations themselves. They just enter a few basic numbers, like clicks on the link, the budget, expected reach, and the tool handles the rest, calculating everything else automatically.
Setting clear goals
A lot of marketers walk into influencer campaigns thinking they can just set SMART goals and run the numbers like they do with paid ads. They want a predictable ROI, clear KPIs, exact conversions, even exact cost per acquisition. And on paper, it makes sense. Influencer marketing should work the same way, right?
The reality is very different. Influencer marketing lives in the world of human behavior, not algorithms. You can’t control what people will do when they see a post, a story, or a video. You can’t guarantee clicks, sign-ups, or purchases the way you can with search or display ads. Trying to apply strict marketing principles to influencer campaigns sets you up for frustration, disappointment, and a constant feeling that the campaign “failed.”
The consequences are subtle but costly. Marketers set unrealistic expectations, constantly measure performance against impossible standards, and write off campaigns prematurely. They obsess over conversion numbers that were never fully predictable, overlooking the actual value happening behind the scenes — audience awareness, engagement quality, brand affinity. Budgets are cut, relationships with influencers suffer, and future campaigns are abandoned before they’ve had a chance to show real impact.
The fix isn’t complicated, but it requires a shift in mindset.
-
Instead of trying to set exact conversion goals, approach influencer campaigns with predictive metrics and qualitative insights.
-
Focus on reach, estimated impressions, engagement patterns, sentiment, and how your audience interacts with the content.
-
Track signals that matter, like authentic comments, shares, saves, and story completion rates.
-
Use these as indicators of long-term brand impact rather than short-term, rigid ROI targets.
For example, instead of saying, “We want a 15% conversion rate over three months,” a more realistic approach is to look at reach and engagement first.
You might aim for a creator to reach 50,000 to 100,000 people with authentic impressions, see 3,000–5,000 meaningful engagements, or achieve 1,500–2,000 story completions over the campaign period. These numbers are achievable, measurable, and give a sense of how well the content is resonating.
On the other hand, setting rigid goals like “we need 500 clicks per post and exactly 10 purchases per link” is unrealistic. You can’t control how an audience will respond, and hitting precise conversions is basically a guessing game.
Influencer marketing is not a spreadsheet exercise. It’s closer to building a relationship between your brand, the creator, and their audience. You can predict approximate reach, measure sentiment, and analyze engagement trends, but you cannot precisely forecast what people will do with the product. Accepting this unpredictability allows you to plan campaigns smarter, optimize in real-time, and recognize success in ways traditional marketing frameworks often miss.
Ignoring disclosure guidelines
One of the biggest common influencer marketing mistakes brands make with influencer marketing is ignoring disclosure guidelines. It might seem minor, after all, it’s just a little “#ad” or “sponsored” somewhere in the post, right? But skipping this step can create a cascade of problems.
-
First, it’s a legal risk. Regulatory bodies like the FTC in the U.S., or similar authorities worldwide, take undisclosed partnerships seriously.Influencers and brands can get fined, and suddenly a campaign that was supposed to build trust instead becomes a headache filled with warnings and penalties.
-
Second, it’s a trust issue. If people feel misled, if they find out a recommendation was paid for and it wasn’t disclosed clearly, engagement drops, credibility erodes, and both the influencer and the brand take a hit.
The fix?
Make disclosure non-negotiable in every brief and contract. Specify where it should appear (in captions, within videos, in stories) and explain how it should be visible to the audience.
Monitor compliance actively. It’s not enough to assume the influencer knows what’s acceptable; you have to check, guide, and sometimes remind.
Why is the first example effective and the second one not?
The first one is clear about the paid partnership, using the proper tag and putting “AD” right at the top of the description, so the audience knows immediately. The second example, on the other hand, skips any kind of disclosure, leaving viewers in the dark and creating potential trust and compliance issues.
Read also: FTC influencer guidelines. 2026 Guide for brands & creators
Mistakes of mobile games in influencer marketing
One of the biggest and common mistakes in influencer marketing mobile games make is overlooking the user experience across platforms.
You’ll see campaigns where an influencer posts a tutorial or gameplay video, but the game’s UI isn’t optimized for mobile versus desktop.
⛔ Buttons are too small, menus are confusing, or loading times are inconsistent.
For an audience watching a slick influencer demo, this disconnect immediately breaks trust. People expect the same smooth experience they saw in the video, and when reality doesn’t match, frustration spreads fast.
⛔ Another issue is the help section on mobile is much more limited than on desktop, usually offering only basic support or guidance specific to mobile issues, like cookies or display problems.)
Image source.
⛔ Performance and speed issues aren’t just minor annoyances either. Long loading times, heavy animations, or large assets can make a game unplayable on some devices, undermining the credibility of the influencer’s recommendation.
⛔ And finally, branding inconsistencies, like oversized logos or poorly adapted graphics, can make the mobile version feel clunky or unpolished compared to what users saw in the influencer content.
Image source.
These issues often spiral into bigger influencer marketing controversy. Influencers get called out in comments, audience trust erodes, and complaints can trend across forums or social media.
Suddenly a campaign that was supposed to drive excitement becomes a reputation risk. It's all about the gap between expectation and reality that was entirely preventable.
The solution is straightforward but requires attention before any campaign goes live:
-
Test the game thoroughly on every platform, making sure buttons, menus, and interactions work smoothly.
-
Optimize performance and speed for mobile devices, ensure the help section covers common questions across both platforms, and adjust visuals so logos and branding remain clean and consistent.
-
If some features are desktop-only or look different on mobile, communicate that transparently. When done right, the influencer amplifies excitement without creating frustration.
Mom influencer marketing mistakes
Pushing products that don’t actually fit the influencer’s lifestyle or parenting style is one of the classic influencer marketing bad practice. I see it all the time: a brand sends a fancy stroller to a mom influencer who primarily shares content about quick, practical life hacks or budget-friendly parenting. The influencer posts it, but it feels forced. The caption doesn’t flow naturally, the video is awkward, and the audience notices immediately.
The consequences?
- Engagement is low, comments are skeptical, and followers start questioning whether the influencer genuinely uses the product.
- The campaign looks polished, but it fails to convert.
- Even worse, the influencer’s trust with their audience takes a hit because it feels like they’re promoting something out of context. Suddenly, a campaign that should build brand affinity turns into a case of influencer marketing gone wrong.
The fix is simple in theory, harder in practice. Brands need to match products to influencers whose content, tone, and values naturally align. Instead of just thinking, “She’s a mom with lots of followers, she’s perfect,” take a closer look at how she talks about parenting, what her routines are, and what her audience expects from her. Let the influencer present the product in their own voice, in real-life contexts.
What about the most famous bad influencer marketing examples 👇
Top 3 influencer marketing fails
Bootea & Scott Disick (2016)
Scott Disick accidentally posted the brand’s instructions, including what time to post and the exact caption he was supposed to use (right in his Instagram caption!).
The post went viral immediately, but not for the reasons the brand hoped.
Why this is such a disaster:
Authenticity completely crumbles.
It’s also a massive process and quality control failure. There was clearly no review step, no “does this read like a human wrote it?” check, and no compliance or final approval before hitting publish. That’s basic influencer campaign hygiene, and skipping it makes even a big-name influencer look careless.
And then there’s the reputational fallout. Even if people are laughing at the mistake, the brand itself gets tagged in everyone’s mind as cheap, spammy, and overly transactional.
That perception sticks, and undoing it is extremely hard. Suddenly, the money spent on the campaign is wasted, and the brand’s credibility is dented for potentially months, all because a simple internal check was ignored.
Fyre Festival (2017)
What happened?
Fyre Festival was promoted by top influencers, including Hailey Bieber and Kendall Jenner, many of whom did not initially disclose that the posts were paid promotions. The posts made it look like a dream experience: private beaches, gourmet food, luxury villas.
In reality, the festival collapsed. There weren’t enough beds, the food was basic at best, and chaos reigned behind the scenes. The promotional posts painted a glamorous picture that was completely detached from what attendees actually experienced.
Image source.
Why was this such a disaster?
-
First, influencer marketing amplified a promise gap. Influencers didn’t just advertise the event — their posts validated it. Their audiences trusted them and assumed, “If this person is attending, it must be amazing.” When reality didn’t match, it felt like betrayal.
-
Second, there was a complete due diligence failure. With an event or experience, influencers’ credibility is on the line. If logistics are sloppy or promises aren’t real, the creators themselves take damage along with the brand. Suddenly, it’s not just the festival that looks bad, the influencers’ reputations are collateral damage.
-
Finally, the campaign became the evidence. Every post, story, and screenshot lives online indefinitely. Even after apologies, those posts are circulating as proof of the failure. Influencer content, intended to build hype, became the receipts people shared when trust broke.
Kim Kardashian & Diclegis
Kim Kardashian promoted Diclegis, a prescription morning sickness medication, in an Instagram post that highlighted benefits. The issue was that it didn’t mention risks or side effects, a legal requirement for prescription drug advertising in the US.
The FDA later issued a warning, calling the post misleading, and it was removed and reposted with proper disclosures.
What went wrong? Health products can’t be promoted like lifestyle items, because missing risk information turns a marketing mistake into a compliance and safety issue.
Image source.
The lesson is straightforward: in health, wellness, and pharma campaigns, legal review and clear disclosures have to be part of the process from the start, not something fixed after publishing.
Want to speed your influencer marketing now 👇
Leverage IQFluence to avoid common mistakes
IQFluence is an AI-powered platform built for TikTok, Instagram, and YouTube, helping brands of all sizes (from e-commerce and SaaS to MarTech and agencies) run smarter influencer marketing campaigns.
One of the things we’re proud of is how the platform helps making data-driven decisions: by helping you discover the right creators, vet and analyze them deeply, and manage campaigns from start to finish.
Here’s how we do it:
-
Influencer search. Stop endless scrolling. With over 15 filters, including location, engagement rate, language, age, semantic search, lookalikes, and last post activity, you can quickly pinpoint creators who align with your goals and values.
-
Influencer + audience analytics. One click gives you growth charts, engagement breakdowns, and real audience insights. You’ll immediately see if an influencer is genuine or inflating numbers with bots, so your campaigns are built on real connections.
-
Media-Plan builder. Create detailed campaign plans in minutes, with metrics sheets, deliverables, and outreach info all in one place. Everything you need to stay organized and consistent.
-
Campaign reporting. Forget messy spreadsheets. IQFluence tracks performance automatically, calculating CPA, CPR, CPC, and all the metrics that actually matter so you can focus on strategy instead of number-crunching.
-
Influencer Outreach. Coming soon. 😉
-
API Integration. Want to run things your way? Plug influencer data straight into your own systems, from CRMs to custom dashboards. The API is ready to go, starting at just $10.
